skip to main content skip to footer

Reviews

may 21, we were in Williamsburg and decided to try your place out. We purchased a few of the appeti
may 21, we were in Williamsburg and decided to try your place out. We purchased a few of the appetizers & each person got something different so we could each get a small sample of the menu. Everything was perfect. Not 1 person in our party of 7 we're dissatisfied. Even our birthday girl who turn 13. She was surprised when you came ... read more
Pamela Gurreri via facebook.com - May 25, 2022
My wife Barbara Home & I enjoyed our 40th anniversary yesterday at the Seafare.
Carl Polnaszek via google.com - May 25, 2022
This is fine dining at its best. The decor is rich in deep color. The booths are a wonderful rich forest green leather with nailhead trim. You are served a sweet bread confection as soon as you are seated. We enjoyed our wine in lovely stem glasses and was served a basket of bread while waiting for our order. A sweet dollop of sorbet ... read more
Linda Caricofe via google.com - May 19, 2022
Everything was great, but it was a little crowded.
maria c via google.com - May 19, 2022
Their Food Is So Great
Everything is great. All was grand. The service was exceptional. The food was wonderful. The experience is always phenomenal.
lovetotravel8686 via tripadvisor.com - May 19, 2022
While staying in the hotel right behind the Seafare we ordered takeout via web site. The order was correct and *absolutely* delicious.
Christopher Morse via google.com - May 17, 2022
The seafare has been such a huge part of some of our families most special times. From engagement t
The seafare has been such a huge part of some of our families most special times. From engagement to honeymoon to anniversaries to daughters big milestone birthdays or just simply for a delicious meal in a very relaxed captivating atmosphere. The staff and owners are top notch and always make you feel welcome. Definitely one our ve ... read more
Beth Padgett via facebook.com - May 11, 2022
The seafare has been such a huge part of some of our families most special times. From engagement to honeymoon to anniversaries to daughters big milestone birthdays or just simply for a delicious meal in a very relaxed captivating atmosphere. The staff and owners are top notch and always make you feel welcome. Definitely one our ve ... read more
Beth Padgett via google.com - May 10, 2022
Far and away the best restaurant we’ve ever eaten at! Everything was served perfectly, food was really delicious and it’s very clean and has beautiful ambiance without feeling too formal. A really unique and wonderful restaurant!
m. sabina via google.com - May 10, 2022
This was our 41st wedding anniversary. We couldn’t have been more surprised to find a wonderful dining experience. The atmosphere was excellent with table linen and a romantic ambience. The crab soup was truly the best I have ever had. The main course was well portioned and prepared well. The food arrived hot through out the cou ... read more
Steven Montgomery via google.com - Apr 25, 2022
good food
Excelant food excellant service most people think this is only a seafood resturant however they have several other items and good veal , steak I Highly recommend this resturant we alwasy visit Seafare when coming to Williamsburg nover had a bad meal ... read more
doloresf833 via tripadvisor.com - Apr 21, 2022
This is one of the best restaurants I have ever dined. Service is great. Meals are superlative.
Robert Phillips via google.com - Apr 15, 2022
Nice atmosphere,great staff, good menu with enough options for everyone. Highly recommend the Irish
Nice atmosphere,great staff, good menu with enough options for everyone. Highly recommend the Irish Coffee for dessert, delicious and actually made at tableside ... read more
Patricia F. via yelp.com - Apr 15, 2022
Excellent if you Select the Right Entree
My friends that selected crab cakes said that they were excellent. Due to my allergies, I chose Wiener Schnitzel that included a few small pieces of veal in a gravy! No fried or crispy coating. This place is very expensive.
Ken_NJ_11islands via tripadvisor.com - Apr 11, 2022
Perfect
From start to finish it was a fabulous experience! The food was excellent! The Super Sauton my wife had, she enjoyed. I had fried oysters which were excellent! The Calamari we had as an appetizer were perfectly done. The House wines were very good. We finished with Pecan pie and Italian coffee. Perfect evening!
raybM708SU via tripadvisor.com - Apr 7, 2022
Food was excellent along with terrific service. Would definitely go back.
Food was excellent along with terrific service. Would definitely go back.
DotR via opentable.com - Apr 3, 2022
What an amazing dining experience. We walked in completely under dressed and they we so welcoming. O
What an amazing dining experience. We walked in completely under dressed and they we so welcoming. Our son had never been to a "fancy" restaurant and he was so excited by the way they treated us. 3 different breads, very friendly and very nice low music. The food was on point and the crab was prevalent in the crab stuffed shrimp. Wha ... read more
Kate B. via yelp.com - Apr 2, 2022
The service was excellent. Kim and his team of helpers were great. The inside was dated. The escargo
The service was excellent. Kim and his team of helpers were great. The inside was dated. The escargot was very good. The other fish and fried oysters and crab were just ok. Not that fresh tasting. All older people in the restaurant.
JenniferK via opentable.com - Apr 1, 2022
Love the decor and service! Loved that we went. A must stop!
Love the decor and service! Loved that we went. A must stop!
OpenTable Diner via opentable.com - Mar 24, 2022
Wonderful dinner last night at Seafare of Williamsburg. The restaurant has a romantic elegance atmos
Wonderful dinner last night at Seafare of Williamsburg. The restaurant has a romantic elegance atmosphere yet one can dress more casual. The food was delicious and the portions were just right. Highly recommend this restaurant.
Sandra W. via yelp.com - Mar 20, 2022
Overall a very good experience. Looks like a family owned and run restaurant, definitely reminiscent
Overall a very good experience. Looks like a family owned and run restaurant, definitely reminiscent of the late 1980s -1990s in terms of decor - white table cloth, lots of decor/light fixtures, full table setting and bread with every course. Old school but charming to be sure. The lime sherbet intermezzo was delightful. We had the c ... read more
Tasty via opentable.com - Mar 19, 2022
Service was professional, prompt, and courteous. Enjoyed our meal from beginning to end. Crab Bisque
Service was professional, prompt, and courteous. Enjoyed our meal from beginning to end. Crab Bisque, Clam Chowder, and Crab Cakes were all great. The Scallops Sauton was absolutely delicious. Loved it.
OpenTable Diner via opentable.com - Feb 27, 2022
Great pre-wedding dinner! Great surf and turf and Kim’s service couldnt be beat! We sat at the back
Great pre-wedding dinner! Great surf and turf and Kim’s service couldnt be beat! We sat at the back at a round table at the back. Excellent evening!
OpenTable Diner via opentable.com - Feb 26, 2022
Was there earlier this week. Staff is attentive and food was delicious! Great atmosphere also.
Ebony Beaver via google.com - Feb 24, 2022
Delicious and good service! Would 100% recommend ... read more
Jayla Freeman via google.com - Feb 19, 2022
We had an awesome meal at the Seafare Saturday evening! Enjoyed the salmon dinner but the crab cakes
We had an awesome meal at the Seafare Saturday evening! Enjoyed the salmon dinner but the crab cakes were fantastic!! The service was superb too! We will be back!
OpenTable Diner via opentable.com - Feb 19, 2022
Great seafood, service, and wine selection.
Jack Godowski via google.com - Feb 16, 2022
Food was delicious but a little expensive (isn't everything these days). Service was not the greates
Food was delicious but a little expensive (isn't everything these days). Service was not the greatest as there didn't seem to be enough servers in this fairly large restaurant. Guess this is due to the pandemic too.
CAROLR via opentable.com - Feb 15, 2022
This was our third time at the Seafare and we were not disappointed. We were promptly seated and our
This was our third time at the Seafare and we were not disappointed. We were promptly seated and our server was there to give us her attention. The food was excellent.
OpenTable Diner via opentable.com - Feb 15, 2022
Lovely decor, excellent food and service!
Lovely decor, excellent food and service!
OpenTable Diner via opentable.com - Feb 12, 2022
Great food, atmosphere, and service.
Great food, atmosphere, and service.
Jackie Fortune via facebook.com - Jan 30, 2022
We first went to the Seafare in early January and enjoyed the experience so much we chose to return
We first went to the Seafare in early January and enjoyed the experience so much we chose to return for our final special dinner before the end of our Williamsburg vacation. The ambience is classy and perfect for a special dinner. Fun nautical theme and nice background music at the correct volume enabling you to speak with your guest ... read more
OpenTable Diner via opentable.com - Jan 29, 2022
The service at the Seafare of Williamsburg was just outstanding. We were greeted at the door and ush
The service at the Seafare of Williamsburg was just outstanding. We were greeted at the door and ushered directly to our table. We were offered bread, water and drinks while we looked at the menu. A small palate cleansing dish of sherbet was served before our entrees. The seafood was fresh and delicious. The portions were hearty. We ... read more
LeaB via opentable.com - Jan 23, 2022
Was a wonderful experience ! Staff were excellent, service was on-point, atmosphere was interesting and had charm, and the food was delicious. All the little details were attended to, like the tongs for the snails (never in all my meals have I had the opportunity to use those) and the complimentary cornbread muffins with dinner. Very ... read more
Kate Klein via google.com - Jan 13, 2022
Our first visit, the tricky part is that my wife is allergic to crab, lobster and shrimp. There was
Our first visit, the tricky part is that my wife is allergic to crab, lobster and shrimp. There was enough good choices to choose from. We enjoyed the meal but service was slow paced, there was only 1 other couple there. With that said, we will return.
RichardF via opentable.com - Jan 12, 2022
If you enjoy fine dining where every detail is committed to excellence; you will enjoy and appreciat
If you enjoy fine dining where every detail is committed to excellence; you will enjoy and appreciate the Seafare.
BarbaraS via opentable.com - Jan 8, 2022
We really enjoyed our meal at The Seafare. I had the veal and my husband had flounder. Perfectly pre
We really enjoyed our meal at The Seafare. I had the veal and my husband had flounder. Perfectly prepared and presented and a very generous portion. I started with the escargot and it too was the perfect temperature and so delicious. The ambiance is wonderful and enhances the entire experience. Service was impeccable. We waited until ... read more
OpenTable Diner via opentable.com - Jan 5, 2022
I love the SeaFare. The menu is a little limited but the food is good. The serviced has always been good. The thing that makes this resturant GREAT is the ambiance. The decor is beautiful and inviting. The soft furnishings also muffle loud noise so you can have conversations and hear each other without screaming.
Sharon Zabriskie via google.com - Jan 1, 2022
Great food and service ... read more
Peter Bloch via google.com - Dec 31, 2021
Birthday celebration. Was wonderful
Birthday celebration. Was wonderful ... read more
OpenTable Diner via opentable.com - Dec 31, 2021
Best seafood restaurant I've eaten in. So good went back a second time and are going again tonight.
Best seafood restaurant I've eaten in. So good went back a second time and are going again tonight. I've never gone to the same restaurant three times in a week. The seafood menu is so large, there is plenty to choose from.
DotD via opentable.com - Dec 28, 2021
Fine dining at its best. Delicious food. Great service. Great value for money.
Fine dining at its best. Delicious food. Great service. Great value for money.
RockHilly via opentable.com - Dec 28, 2021
Excellent restaurant. Best crabmeat stuffed mushrooms I’ve ever had. Wife agreed and the crabmeat on
Excellent restaurant. Best crabmeat stuffed mushrooms I’ve ever had. Wife agreed and the crabmeat on the stuffed shrimp was great. Filet was very good. A little undercooked but still enjoyed it. The vegges did not knock my socks off but I never eat them all. My daughter got the Oscar Medallions and cleared her whole plate. She is pic ... read more
OpenTable Diner via opentable.com - Dec 27, 2021
First time at this iconic spot did not disappoint. Food was nicely presented and delicious and we en
First time at this iconic spot did not disappoint. Food was nicely presented and delicious and we enjoyed our dinner and will be back.
JanetM via opentable.com - Dec 27, 2021
The food was very good and an excellent selection both for seafood lovers & meat lovers. Our waitres
The food was very good and an excellent selection both for seafood lovers & meat lovers. Our waitress was outstanding but overworked due to staff shortages. Given the circumstances they did well overall .
MHOM via opentable.com - Dec 27, 2021
Nice quiet atmosphere. Great food and service.
Jim Sireci via google.com - Dec 25, 2021
The food is absolutely amazing. The veggies were cooked perfectly. The fish n crab cakes did it for me by far the best. The chef does his thing and does it well ... read more
Amanda Monaco via google.com - Dec 25, 2021
My son and I went to Seafare for Christmas Eve dinner. We enjoyed shrimp cocktail, and soups for sta
My son and I went to Seafare for Christmas Eve dinner. We enjoyed shrimp cocktail, and soups for starters. He had the crab cakes & I had the flounder. All of the food was delicious. The restaurant was packed so the service was a little slow. But considering it was Christmas Eve - they did a great job. Will definitely go there again.
Debbie via opentable.com - Dec 24, 2021
Wonderful food
Our group had dinner here and we had excellent service. A wonderful place to come for seafood. Everyone at the table enjoyed their meal.
Ned K via tripadvisor.com - Dec 22, 2021
We took our whole family to eat here on vacation. Everyone’s food was delicious and the service was
We took our whole family to eat here on vacation. Everyone’s food was delicious and the service was exceptional.
OpenTable Diner via opentable.com - Dec 22, 2021
We had a family Christmas gathering of 11 and everyone enjoyed ages 12 to 83.
We had a family Christmas gathering of 11 and everyone enjoyed ages 12 to 83.
BonnieH via opentable.com - Dec 21, 2021
Went here to celebrate my wife's birthday and had a great meal. Her salmon was delicious and my flounder was very good. The sorbet after our soup and salad was a nice touch. Prices were very reasonable and we wouldn't hesitate to return for another great meal.
Charles Barhite via google.com - Dec 19, 2021
Excellent dining experience. Waiter was attentive without hovering or making us feel rushed. Would r
Excellent dining experience. Waiter was attentive without hovering or making us feel rushed. Would recommend.
CherylW via opentable.com - Dec 17, 2021
My husband and I ate here as out-of-towners. Both our entrées were delicious. Our server was very polite and attentive. The inside of the restaurant is nice and clean. It's not new and trendy, but more like a time capsule. I felt Wisconsin supper club vibes. We would eat here again.
Dana McClellan via google.com - Dec 13, 2021
Fantastic ... read more
Becci Simons via google.com - Dec 13, 2021
Very good restaurant. My wife had scallops with peppers and mushrooms. I had the veal Oscar. We both
Very good restaurant. My wife had scallops with peppers and mushrooms. I had the veal Oscar. We both had pecan pie for desert which was excellent ... read more
Woundedwhale via opentable.com - Dec 12, 2021
This was my 87th Birthday dinner and it was SPECTACULAR! The Crab Bisque was so delicious as was the
This was my 87th Birthday dinner and it was SPECTACULAR! The Crab Bisque was so delicious as was the Wiener Schnitsel, Rice Pilaf and veggies. The Peach Melba was also a visural and taste treat! Our waitress was a delight and we hope to come back again for my husband's birthday in April as well as our anniversary in late June. What a ... read more
CarmenL via opentable.com - Dec 11, 2021
The steak was not seasoned at all but the rest of the food was really delicious.
Akeysa Brockington via google.com - Dec 10, 2021
Old fashion setting , service was great and server was pleasant and knowledgeable. We had the salmon
Old fashion setting , service was great and server was pleasant and knowledgeable. We had the salmon and scallop dishes which were delicious and cooked to perfection! They brought homemade cornbread and sherbet between courses. Unfortunately we had no room for dessert. Highly recommend!
OpenTable Diner via opentable.com - Dec 9, 2021
Great atmosphere, food and service. Very clean restaurant and pleasant staff.
Great atmosphere, food and service. Very clean restaurant and pleasant staff.
Nicholas via opentable.com - Dec 6, 2021
First time visit to the restaurant, every aspect was on target, food was excellent. Looking forward
First time visit to the restaurant, every aspect was on target, food was excellent. Looking forward to visiting again when we come back.
FredF via opentable.com - Dec 5, 2021
The service was excellent. my husband had the veal oscar which was tender and flavorful. I had the g
The service was excellent. my husband had the veal oscar which was tender and flavorful. I had the grouper which was also tasty.
gretchenk via opentable.com - Dec 4, 2021
Great service and food.
Chris Smith via google.com - Dec 3, 2021
Excellent Food and Service
Visiting Williamsburg, Virginia on 12/03/21, my wife and I ate dinner at Seafare. One couldn't have asked for better food or service anywhere in the country. The Veal Oscar was impeccably done, fork tender and perfectly seasoned. Junior was our waitstaff and attended our every need speedily and efficiently. Well worth the price!
jayl226 via tripadvisor.com - Dec 3, 2021
From our first conversation on the phone to walking out the door of their restaurant after dinner these people treated us like special friends. We planned a surprise party for our daughter. They gave us an alcove that fit all of us nicely. We were able to come in early and decorate. They seemed to have as much fun as we did ! W ... read more
Faith Murdock via google.com - Dec 2, 2021
Awesome as always. Delicious food every time. The stuffed crab shrimp is a great meal. Friendly and great atmosphere.
Denise Kazee via google.com - Dec 2, 2021
Delightful wait staff, delicious food, intimate atmosphere. Rainbow trout, stuffed with crab, rice pilaf, mixed vegetables, cornbread... even the water was delicious (really).
Christal Jenkins via google.com - Nov 27, 2021
It was wonderful! Definitely a great place for a nice date or equivalent get-together. All the cours
It was wonderful! Definitely a great place for a nice date or equivalent get-together. All the courses were equally delicious, and separated with refreshing palate cleansers.
OpenTable Diner via opentable.com - Nov 27, 2021
If anyone is looking for a nice dinner, this is the place.
If anyone is looking for a nice dinner, this is the place.
DanW via opentable.com - Nov 27, 2021
The food was delicious, and my granddaughter and I loved the ambiance of the room. We will come agai
The food was delicious, and my granddaughter and I loved the ambiance of the room. We will come again.
CynthiaB via opentable.com - Nov 27, 2021
Want To Tell Us About Your Experience?
GoogleMyBusinessFoursquareFacebookYelpZomatoTwitterTrip AdvisorYouTubeGrouponInstagramOpen TablePinterestZagatFlickrLinkedInTumblrTheKnotWeddingWire