skip to main content skip to footer

Reviews

Our Wedding Anniversary
Great service, great food. Karen was a excellent waitress, Thank you! I would everybody advise to eat here.
lizabethford via tripadvisor.com - Jun 30, 2020
The food , freshness and presentation were simply amazing! What brought this fantastic dining experience full circle was the professional attentive staff! The manager even came out along with the chef and engaged in a very authentic conversation that was truly welcoming! I will return when I travel to the area because my family lives ... read more
Calvin Cherry via google.com - Jun 24, 2020
So beautiful & the food was delicious . we were treated so nicely . it was a great experience 😋💙✨
So beautiful & the food was delicious . we were treated so nicely . it was a great experience 😋💙✨ ... read more
Ellie Ruiz via facebook.com - Jun 24, 2020
Good food, great service and ambiance. We like to drive down a couple of times a year for the food.
LMCW via opentable.com - Jun 21, 2020
Very soothing atmosphere my husband and I enjoyed a quiet dinner for two. Delicious food our waitre
Very soothing atmosphere my husband and I enjoyed a quiet dinner for two. Delicious food our waitress was definitely on top of things. We’ll definitely go back again.
Brenda Lewis Davenport via facebook.com - Jun 21, 2020
Sunday fun day
This was our first time visiting the restaurant. The atmosphere,food and service was delicious. Jester was our server he was very helpful and an excellent waiter. We enjoyed our first experience and will definitely will be back soon.
406mavisj via tripadvisor.com - Jun 14, 2020
Fantastic 1st visit
Our visit was great from beginning to start. Jester, our server, was so courteous. His service was excellent and made our experience very special. The food was delicious and presentation was appealing. We were celebrating our 6 year anniversary. The hostess and Jester made it...More ... read more
anoneill7 via tripadvisor.com - Jun 14, 2020
Excellent Restaurant
While on a buisness trip with my husband (10 years ago), we found this restaurant. He ordered a shrimp dish and I ordered the delmonico steak. We still talk about how wonderful the atmosphere was and how delicious the food was. We hope to venture...More ... read more
TKMAOM via tripadvisor.com - May 18, 2020
Anniversary Dinner
This restaurant came highly recommended, My wife and I celebrated our anniversary here. The atmosphere was amazing, the food was delicious and plentiful. We would recommend this to anyone and we will be back.
Dale0918 via tripadvisor.com - Apr 15, 2020
Might be the best food Ive ever gotten to eat. Had a great time and overall awesome experience. Best word to describe Seafare is very Creative, the building itself to the inside decor even down to the food and plate presentation. It was delicious food. Sucks that we were just visiting and cant come more frequently!
Batman Briggs via google.com - Mar 30, 2020
Food and service was great!
Quinton Pace via google.com - Mar 15, 2020
Excellent food and attentive service. A pleasure dining at Seafare Williamsburg ... read more
Atlanta via opentable.com - Mar 14, 2020
We celebrated my mother’s birthday here, and the food was excellent!! The atmosphere is very soothi
We celebrated my mother’s birthday here, and the food was excellent!! The atmosphere is very soothing and relaxing. The service was a little slow, but overall it was a really good experience. I certainly would go back again!!❤️ ... read more
Andrea Sutton via facebook.com - Mar 9, 2020
My filet mignon was perfect ... read more
Rebecca McCluskey via google.com - Mar 6, 2020
Definitely 5 star restaurant. The atmosphere is very relaxing and the service was excellent. The crab cakes were top notch along with awesome corn muffins. My wife had the steak and lobster...no complaint out of her. She also enjoyed the cheesecake which was spot on. When I can make the wife happy..I'm happy. I have passed by this ... read more
William Carrington via google.com - Mar 2, 2020
We had heard mixed things about ...
We had heard mixed things about the Seafare of Williamsburg. Still it was a special occasion so we decided to give it a try. The decor is a little dated but the restaurant is spotless and you can tell it was once very luxurious. The service was excellent.  They were very attentive and kind. My husband had the fillet mignon and I had ... read more
Eileen W. via yelp.com - Feb 23, 2020
what a great place to enjoy a wonderful meal with a wonderful staff
My wife and I enjoyed a very nice valentines day dinner at the Sea fare of Williams burg,we really enjoyed the the meal we started with the crab dip,this was the best thing ever,I have had a lot of crab dips at a lot of...More ... read more
sassy1262016 via tripadvisor.com - Feb 19, 2020
Mom visiting ... read more
OpenTable Diner via opentable.com - Feb 16, 2020
We went to the Seafare tonight ...
We went to the Seafare tonight for Valentine's Day. (We are from NJ). We would actually give it 4.5 stars. We had a 5:45 reservation & they took us on time. Our waiter, Mico, was OUTSTANDING. Very professional and it was clear he took his job seriously. He gave us good, truthful, feedback & recommendations on various dishes & drinks.
S M. via yelp.com - Feb 14, 2020
My wife and I always enjoy having dinner at the Seafare.
BobbyH via opentable.com - Feb 14, 2020
Server was excellent. Food very good ... read more
BarryC via opentable.com - Feb 13, 2020
I have eaten here twice. Both times were big failures. The service was slow. They were really understaffed and they ran out of several items on the menu. I wont be back.
Richard Hogan via google.com - Feb 9, 2020
I went late so I could book a 1,000 point table, so maybe that's why the place was basically empty, but I wonder if there are other reasons. The greeting and service was excellent. The decor not so much. The place could use a good upgrading and modernization. The threadbare carpets in places do not speak well for the restaurant.
BR549 via opentable.com - Jan 25, 2020
Great food, clean, and great service!!
Great food, clean, and great service!!
Linda Modelfino via facebook.com - Jan 25, 2020
We always expect a super meal from The Seafare.. this was no exception... we both had the beef tourneados and they were so tender... The staff is very professional an courteous. A very relaxing evening and wonderful ambience.
CathyW via opentable.com - Jan 15, 2020
Very nice quiet and peaceful ambiance. The service was excellent. Very good variety of options on the menu and the food was delicious. This was our first visit but we will definitely be returning.
ThomasF via opentable.com - Jan 11, 2020
a nice place for a special dinner good food ... read more
Ian Fisher via google.com - Jan 9, 2020
Really nice upscale atmosphere. The service was wonderful and very proper. We felt underdressed given the surroundings. Our meals were delivered without errors and everyone enjoyed a delicious meal. The Seafood was excellent and tasted fresh. It was not very crowded the night we visited.
Timothy Glenn via google.com - Jan 9, 2020
Food and service good. It was packed on Christmas eve.
Chris White via google.com - Jan 9, 2020
Excellent food, service and great locatiin right on Richmond Rd.
Barbara Krueger via google.com - Jan 9, 2020
Enjoyed a wonderful dinner with family the last night we were in Williamsburg. Beautiful restaurant with a nautical theme, very clean, nice soft music. The waitress was great. Answered all of our menu questions and was very attentive to our needs. The food was amazing. We had baked grouper, a very nice size filet with vegetables, ver ... read more
DM50 via opentable.com - Jan 4, 2020
This restaurant is an old gem for Williamsburg. It is dependable and has a sufficiently broad enough menu to offer variety for repeat visits and consistency to make it a place for a specific preference available every visit. Both taste and presentation of the food is very good.
PaulS via opentable.com - Jan 1, 2020
We enjoyed our New Years/wedding anniversary dinner at Seafare. One would not want to dine in haste there -- you'll choose and receive your drinks well before your food order is taken, and the pace is unhurried. Can't remember the last time we dined for nearly two hours. The staff are courteous, the food well prepared (we really like ... read more
Wonderful via opentable.com - Jan 1, 2020
Thank you to the owners Demetirus and his mother for making our experience in their restaurant a wo
Thank you to the owners Demetirus and his mother for making our experience in their restaurant a wonderful one. Beginning with a fabulous wine recommendation to accompany our delicious dinner. Our evening ended with a baklava cheesecake. We highly recommend this family owned restaurant.
Gidon Lahav via facebook.com - Jan 1, 2020
Best overall restaurant owner/manager—Demetris—in Williamsburg.
EdConn via opentable.com - Dec 24, 2019
Lovely evening and meal
We found this restaurant during a short trip to Williamsburg - a place with no shortage of restaurants. We thoroughly enjoyed our time there - the host and wait staff were friendly and accommodating, the food was delicious (and plentiful!), and the decor and ambience...More ... read more
SUJDH via tripadvisor.com - Dec 23, 2019
The setting, decorations, service, and food were all great. A special restaurant. Good place for ordinary dining as well as for special occasions.
JudithR via opentable.com - Dec 21, 2019
The food and service was amazing here. This was our first visit, but we will be returning.The only "negative", if you can even call it one...the lighting is a little dim to give the ambiance, so if you need light to read, make sure you have some way to overcome that.
BusinessCasual via opentable.com - Dec 14, 2019
Nice relaxing dinner - enjoyed free app through reservation via Open Table! ( Crab and artichoke dip was good!) The salmon was very good. Nice size salads! Definitely a place we will return to next time in Williamsburg !
SherylR via opentable.com - Dec 12, 2019
Excellent food and service
This was our second time at Seafare Restaurant we were here a few years ago and looked forward to returning the service was excellent and the food was even better we did have reservations so did not have to wait for a table price was...More ... read more
doloresf833 via tripadvisor.com - Dec 10, 2019
Delicious dinner. Friendly staff. Lovely place.
Brooke Totman via google.com - Dec 9, 2019
First time and not disappointed!
Four of us including one child went for a Saturday night. Got reservations for an early 6 pm dinner. Food was delicious, service was attentive, seating was very comfortable. They can accomodate large parties too! I will return!
Birthday-Gal via tripadvisor.com - Dec 9, 2019
Terrific love the atmosphere ... read more
Ray Sterner via google.com - Dec 9, 2019
Fantastic food and service !!! Will be back in the near future. Thanks ... read more
Charli via opentable.com - Dec 8, 2019
I had crab cakes which were excellent. The prices were high but worth it.
PatriciaT via opentable.com - Dec 8, 2019
Adam was amazing, he treated my 8-year-old daughter like a little princess. Our food was timely and delicious but it left us too full for dessert LOL. I can't wait to come back and try the crab stuffed shrimp.
ChadaM via opentable.com - Dec 1, 2019
Wonderful Thanksgiving dinner, very nice service, excellent price ... read more
DanielaS via opentable.com - Nov 29, 2019
We enjoyed our visit to Seafare ...
We enjoyed our visit to Seafare very much. The staff was very friendly and attentive. Food was very good. My husband ordered the seafood platter and I ordered the New York strip. Both meals were delicious. It was very busy and the staff handled it well. We will be back again!
Shannon H. via yelp.com - Nov 29, 2019
Excellent experience in fine dining
Excellent experience in fine dining ... read more
Joseph Minarczyk via facebook.com - Nov 29, 2019
Good food and service. Tonight we had special four course Thanksgiving dinner.
Good food and service. Tonight we had special four course Thanksgiving dinner.
Joe Lam via facebook.com - Nov 28, 2019
We enjoyed our visit to seafare. Food was great, service was excellent and the experience was great. Will visit again.
ShannonH via opentable.com - Nov 28, 2019
Very welcoming and accommodating. Worth the price. Great food
Very welcoming and accommodating. Worth the price. Great food ... read more
Brandon Collins via facebook.com - Nov 12, 2019
Nice ambience! The food is good but maybe not great. There was nothing really special about the food. However, the environment was cool and comfy. Kid-friendly too! Our waiter (Karen) showed professionalism and sure looked like she enjoys what she does.
Moyoforeoluwa Fadiran via google.com - Nov 9, 2019
Our party of fifteen was seated at two adjacent tables in Seafare's more formal dining room. Fine food and excellent courteous service is what you expect and get at this restaurant. I had not been to the Seafare for several years and wondered if the quality of the restaurant would be maintained. The Seafare deserves and gets fiv ... read more
Judy Bowers via google.com - Nov 9, 2019
Best crabcakes ever!
Lynda Weitz via google.com - Nov 9, 2019
What a nice dining experience! Beautiful restaurant. We were in the Cruising Room. Looks just like an old dining room on a cruise ship. Five stars. Food excellent. Service excellent from Karen. Candlelight, linen tablecloths and napkins, quality tableware. Amazing menu. They even serve sherbet before the main course to cleanse your ... read more
Pamela Pinson via google.com - Nov 9, 2019
The Food was excellent and you could not ask for any better Waiter's and Waitresses. The place is very Beautiful in inside. Thank You for singing Happy Birthday to our Mom. Today she turned 74.
Tammy Sowards via google.com - Nov 9, 2019
Classic 60s fare. Expect to see Frank Sinatra and Dean Martin stroll in.
Lynn Burcher via google.com - Nov 9, 2019
Great food and service.
Bob Green via google.com - Nov 9, 2019
The food, 12 oysters and two fish dishes, was excellent. Oysters were fresh and well shucked, the stuffed trout and fried platter could not have been better. Service was prompt, cheerful, and professional. Overall, this was a delightful first experience and one we plan to repeat.
RichardL via opentable.com - Nov 2, 2019
Exceptional service Excellent food choices from menuRomantic atmosphere Clean5-star dining
Exceptional service Excellent food choices from menu Romantic atmosphere Clean 5-star dining ... read more
Pamela J. Justice-Pinson via facebook.com - Oct 27, 2019
The service was good. Our food was as described and very good.
LindaR via opentable.com - Oct 26, 2019
This was the first time we have dined at The Seafare of Williamsburg. The interior was very well decorated. We were greeted at the door and immediately taken to our table. We made reservations. Our waitress was wonderful! The food was outstanding. My husband and I shared escargot as an appetizer which was great!Wine selection ... read more
guernsey59 via opentable.com - Oct 17, 2019
Everyone enjoyed their food. I was a bit disappointed, I ordered the crab stuffed shrimp and substituted mashed potatoes. They brought out crab cakes with mashed potatoes. I sent it back, and they brought out the shrimp with rice. I'm a waitress and it's the little details that can make it or break it. Otherwise though, the food was ... read more
RebeccaO via opentable.com - Oct 12, 2019
Want To Tell Us About Your Experience?
GoogleMyBusinessFoursquareFacebookYelpZomatoTwitterTrip AdvisorYouTubeGrouponInstagramOpen TablePinterestZagatFlickrLinkedInTumblrTheKnotWeddingWire