skip to main content skip to footer

Reviews

This is my absolute favorite restaurant in the entire US. We went last night for our anniversary and
This is my absolute favorite restaurant in the entire US. We went last night for our anniversary and I wish I remembered our waitress's name but she was absolutely amazing and so was the food. If the owners see this it was to the left of the entrance at the first table on the right at about 5:30 pm. I would love if you would praise h ... read more
Alicia R. via yelp.com - Jul 25, 2021
The inside of the restaurant was absolutely beautiful. was like exquisite dining on a luxury cruise
The inside of the restaurant was absolutely beautiful. was like exquisite dining on a luxury cruise line. Food was delicious. Staff was very friendly and professional. Would rate this a "9"! Always room for improvement. But I don't know what they could do.
Carolann Adams via facebook.com - Jul 22, 2021
Omg this was like the best of everything the greatest meal ever and you can't beat the price ... read more
Paula Wauhop via google.com - Jul 10, 2021
Very good food ... read more
Clifton Brown via google.com - Jul 7, 2021
Awesome dinner. Awesome service. Highly recommend.
greg smith via google.com - Jul 7, 2021
Great service . Great food ... read more
Jay Lycan via google.com - Jun 30, 2021
We’ve visited a few times and are always impressed with the service and food. It’s a must try— you w
We’ve visited a few times and are always impressed with the service and food. It’s a must try— you will want to return, I promise!
kellymB2293CQ via tripadvisor.com - Jun 30, 2021
Some food was good, esp fried oysters, scallops. Others were under seasoned. The mango sorbet pallet
Some food was good, esp fried oysters, scallops. Others were under seasoned. The mango sorbet pallet reset was very good. We didn’t mind the darkness, and the server was very nice and not overbearing. Service was a little slow despite not having too many present. Overall, we’d come back.
OpenTable Diner via opentable.com - Jun 28, 2021
Everything was Awesome. Couldn't have been better. 4 of us and everyone's food was delicious. Very a
Everything was Awesome. Couldn't have been better. 4 of us and everyone's food was delicious. Very attentive ... read more
896christianner via tripadvisor.com - Jun 28, 2021
Great family restaurant ... read more
Kevin Horn via google.com - Jun 27, 2021
Nice. Superb food and service
Nice. Superb food and service ... read more
Melinda Blue via facebook.com - Jun 25, 2021
This week we had two wonderful dinners at Seafare of Williamsburg on different nights. The food was
This week we had two wonderful dinners at Seafare of Williamsburg on different nights. The food was so good on our first visit that we had to return. The food was superb and the service was exceptional.
Farid J Sabongi via facebook.com - Jun 25, 2021
Excellent food and service
Excellent food and service ... read more
Hgrabkow via opentable.com - Jun 24, 2021
A little dark inside, making reading the menu difficult. Said from that, we had a wonderful meal and
A little dark inside, making reading the menu difficult. Said from that, we had a wonderful meal and experience.
OpenTable Diner via opentable.com - Jun 20, 2021
Fabulous food, good prices, service is great! I have dined here for decades, and the experience has
Fabulous food, good prices, service is great! I have dined here for decades, and the experience has always been exemplary. One of my favorites here in Williamsburg !
rjcfabs via tripadvisor.com - Jun 19, 2021
Great food and service. Very fresh seafood.
Great food and service. Very fresh seafood.
Porkstuff via opentable.com - Jun 15, 2021
Delicious food, exceptional service, amazing experience, beautiful atmosphere, would love to visit again!
SaranghaeBTSDaily via google.com - Jun 11, 2021
The atmosphere was very cozy. The staff was attentive to us. Plus everyone very friendly & polite. The food was delicious. We will definitely return ... read more
Towana Harris-Lawson via google.com - Jun 7, 2021
This place has a great atmosphere. We love the decor and lighted pictures on the walls. Gives a rom
This place has a great atmosphere. We love the decor and lighted pictures on the walls. Gives a romantic feel. The bathroom needs to be updated to reflect the same atmosphere as the restaurant but overall, it’s a really nice and elegant setting. Food is really delicious! Their seafood is top of the line and their 12 oz steak was so t ... read more
Aleshia Condia Long via facebook.com - Jun 6, 2021
We had an enjoyable dinner - but they are not offering the fixed price multi-course dinners. We were
We had an enjoyable dinner - but they are not offering the fixed price multi-course dinners. We were served 3 kinds of bread, which were all excellent.
Irene L via tripadvisor.com - Jun 1, 2021
We had a wonderful time. Our waitress was amazing and the food was GREAT! We loved the atmosphere and highly recommend Seafare if you are looking for a romantic dinner and great seafood!
Katie Reid via google.com - May 31, 2021
Great Food. Slow Service.
Clark Hemingway via google.com - May 30, 2021
We have always enjoyed this restaurant! It’s a step back in time both in style of service, decor and
We have always enjoyed this restaurant! It’s a step back in time both in style of service, decor and menu. Service is gracious and timely. The food is tasty and well portioned with no surprises or missing elements. We will return!
ALT1 via opentable.com - May 25, 2021
love the food and the staff was amazing
love the food and the staff was amazing ... read more
Priscilla Phillips via facebook.com - May 16, 2021
Excellent experience for fine dining. Very romantic anytime we visit Williamsburg we have decided to make this our special place ... read more
Pashun 4 Life via google.com - May 15, 2021
The food was great.
Scott Rauenzahn via google.com - May 14, 2021
We had reservations and were seated quickly. Server was very attentive. We had grilled oysters, crab
We had reservations and were seated quickly. Server was very attentive. We had grilled oysters, crab bisque. Followed that with serf and turf. Grilled Lobster was best I have had anywhere. Everything was excellent. Wish I lived here because we would eat here often.
scott via opentable.com - May 11, 2021
Service was slow and the server kept forgetting items. There were a lot of apologies, and i appreciate that. However, it was a bit too much. One thing that i just can not over look is the fact that they used milk instead of cream for coffee. This is a big problem, it's not hard to order milk. Keep you restaurant stocked!
Thom Wells via google.com - May 10, 2021
Food is excellent and service was great
Food is excellent and service was great ... read more
Edward Silva via facebook.com - May 9, 2021
We splurged on a special night out while on vacation and chose the Seafare which was highly recommen
We splurged on a special night out while on vacation and chose the Seafare which was highly recommended. I did not expect the lovely interior and fine dining that we experienced. Wait staff was on point and courteous, food was delicious and dessert selection was perfectly varied. This was a wonderful meal and atmosphere to linger ove ... read more
tagjr56 via tripadvisor.com - May 9, 2021
Both food and service were excellent.
Amy Fink via google.com - May 8, 2021
An excellent meal. Understaffed, at the moment. Our server, Mary, did her best!
An excellent meal. Understaffed, at the moment. Our server, Mary, did her best!
smiley422 via opentable.com - May 8, 2021
This is a nice seafood restaurant. The food is excellent and the staff is very attentive.
This is a nice seafood restaurant. The food is excellent and the staff is very attentive.
Williamsburg via opentable.com - May 8, 2021
Food was excellent, our server was somewhat inexperienced, but very friendly. Limited choice of side
Food was excellent, our server was somewhat inexperienced, but very friendly. Limited choice of side items (baked potato or rice). They served 3 different types of bread, all very good. Entrees were a little pricey, but very good.
HenryK via opentable.com - May 7, 2021
Food was delicious, but the best part was the service. Victoria is the best!
Food was delicious, but the best part was the service. Victoria is the best!
LouiseR via opentable.com - May 1, 2021
Great Romantic Dinner spot with exceptional food. We never felt rushed and it was a great dining exp
Great Romantic Dinner spot with exceptional food. We never felt rushed and it was a great dining experience. There were many wonderful choices on the menu and it would have been easy to go back several nights. This is our favorite place to go in Williamsburg.
RobertR via opentable.com - Apr 30, 2021
We had a wonderful experience at the Seafarer last night. The food was fabulous! Our server Christin
We had a wonderful experience at the Seafarer last night. The food was fabulous! Our server Christine was excellent, so pleasant and efficient! The general manager, Howard, stopped by our table to say “hello” and truly topped off the evening with his outgoing personality. I highly recommend this restaurant!!
MarlynZ via opentable.com - Apr 26, 2021
This is a great place for a quiet special dinner. The ambiance is quiet and fancy. The service is ex
This is a great place for a quiet special dinner. The ambiance is quiet and fancy. The service is excellent. The food is very good and the price is very reasonable for a "fancy restaurant".
JonathanW via opentable.com - Apr 25, 2021
Exelente servicio y todo delicioso ... read more
Connie Villareal via google.com - Apr 24, 2021
We go here everytime we go to Williamsburg. Crab cakes are amazing!
Michael Koehl via google.com - Apr 22, 2021
Love the stuffed shrimp with crab
Love the stuffed shrimp with crab ... read more
Karla Johanna Etheridge via facebook.com - Apr 22, 2021
We had a really nice experience at the Seafare. The service, background music and food quality was t
We had a really nice experience at the Seafare. The service, background music and food quality was to the level that we will come back again when we’re in town.
Frank via opentable.com - Apr 20, 2021
Very best service and atmosphere. Seafood well prepared and tasty!
Very best service and atmosphere. Seafood well prepared and tasty!
OpenTable Diner via opentable.com - Apr 20, 2021
Steak and Seafood Platter was delicious! Beautiful cozy place with great service.
Steak and Seafood Platter was delicious! Beautiful cozy place with great service.
Kathy via opentable.com - Apr 20, 2021
This was outstanding! Party of 6, 4 adults 2 older children. 6 different entrees, 3 apps. All were e
This was outstanding! Party of 6, 4 adults 2 older children. 6 different entrees, 3 apps. All were excellent. A great fine dining experience for adults and fine kids.
GinaF via opentable.com - Apr 18, 2021
Excellent food and service. They really need to update the descriptions for their menu items though.
Excellent food and service. They really need to update the descriptions for their menu items though. Some of them are plain icky. Otherwise, I highly recommend.
Isaac B. via yelp.com - Apr 13, 2021
Best crab cakes anywhere!! Wonderful ambiance and wait service!
Best crab cakes anywhere!! Wonderful ambiance and wait service!
Nancy Scatton via facebook.com - Apr 12, 2021
Being from NJ, I’ve had lots of crab cakes. These are some of the best I’ve ever had. Fantastic service and great food!
vjeff55 via google.com - Apr 7, 2021
Wonderful dining. Loved the meal and ambiance ... read more
Kenneth Holme via google.com - Apr 7, 2021
Once again we stopped in to the Seafare for dinner. When we are in Williamsburg, this is our must ha
Once again we stopped in to the Seafare for dinner. When we are in Williamsburg, this is our must have. The food is terrific and the service excellent. Our server Nika was exceedingly friendly and jovial during our stay here this evening. We highly recommend this restaurant to anyone who enjoys fine dining and superior food.
jvpritc via tripadvisor.com - Mar 28, 2021
Great surf and turf and the seafood platter was awesome. Will come back again.
Nanette Grace via google.com - Mar 27, 2021
We recently visited the Seafare for dinner for the first time. We really loved the nautical themed d
We recently visited the Seafare for dinner for the first time. We really loved the nautical themed decorations and paintings. The ambience, food, and service were all excellent. I highly recommend it to anyonebfor a night out or special occasion.
AlanW via opentable.com - Mar 27, 2021
Love the food ... read more
Maurice Crandle via google.com - Mar 18, 2021
Amazing food, excellent service...
john Laro via google.com - Mar 16, 2021
I haven't been there in years. However in past years I received great service and great food. I hope it's still there same when I visit soon.
Carlos Martin via google.com - Mar 10, 2021
Excellent ... read more
Xochil Tobar via google.com - Mar 9, 2021
Want To Tell Us About Your Experience?
GoogleMyBusinessFoursquareFacebookYelpZomatoTwitterTrip AdvisorYouTubeGrouponInstagramOpen TablePinterestZagatFlickrLinkedInTumblrTheKnotWeddingWire