skip to main content skip to footer

Reviews

Had dinner here tonight the waitress I believe her name was melanie was very attentive and helpful she was wonderful. The food was delicious and the atmosphere was relaxing .
George Mccreight via google.com - Sep 21, 2021
Service and food were both excellent! 😋 ... read more
Lucy Naturale via google.com - Sep 20, 2021
Unparalleled dining experience. Portions were perfect. The seafood platter was outstanding with no heavy coating. The cherries jubilee was amazing as well as the service.
Richard Geml via google.com - Sep 16, 2021
Seafood was excellent, though one dinner mate did not care for her steak. The staff was very friendly and helpful.
John Roby Morsberger via google.com - Sep 5, 2021
They have some of the best bisque I have ever had. The staff was excellent, especially Demetrious.
jamie gapp via google.com - Sep 5, 2021
I went back to seafare and the food was awesome as always. The cheesecake was good too. They never d
I went back to seafare and the food was awesome as always. The cheesecake was good too. They never disappoints ... read more
Lisa J. via yelp.com - Sep 5, 2021
Great place to eat ... read more
james robinson via google.com - Sep 3, 2021
Food was very good. Nice atmosphere. Attentive wait staff.
Food was very good. Nice atmosphere. Attentive wait staff.
garry via opentable.com - Aug 27, 2021
This restaurant is a charming establishment. Don't let the negative reviews you might see deter you.
This restaurant is a charming establishment. Don't let the negative reviews you might see deter you..My wife and I had a great dinner here..I had the scallops and my wife had the crab bisque. Everything was fantastic. Moral of the story is don't listen to the overly embellished negative reviews.
Eric D. via yelp.com - Aug 27, 2021
Went last Monday with my girlfriend. Food is okay, but service is really good 👍 will come back.....
Went last Monday with my girlfriend. Food is okay, but service is really good 👍 will come back.....
LukeJames19925 via tripadvisor.com - Aug 26, 2021
We had an excellent experience at Seafare! The vibe was mid-century cruise ship, but in a cool sophisticated kind of way. The food was excellent and so was the service. It felt like fine dining, but the price was very fair! I'd highly recommend this restaurant!
Caitlyn Hahn via google.com - Aug 25, 2021
I find it hard to believe the negative reviews that I see, I have been eating at this restaurant for
I find it hard to believe the negative reviews that I see, I have been eating at this restaurant for many years and it is still the best place to eat in Williamsburg. I had surf and turf and it was excellent for $39 really that's great. Someone had said you need to dress up, not true at all I don't think they would want you to come i ... read more
donc237 via tripadvisor.com - Aug 22, 2021
We researched so many restaurants on our Williamsburg vacation, but we couldn’t find anything that
We researched so many restaurants on our Williamsburg vacation, but we couldn’t find anything that met all of our family’s needs. We called Seafare to check on a menu item, and they were very accommodating, so we chose to eat our anniversary dinner here. We had no idea what a lovely, upscale atmosphere the restaurant had or how delic ... read more
Kristin Spengler Zerbe via facebook.com - Aug 17, 2021
really good. wonderful customer service
really good. wonderful customer service ... read more
Katie Wilfong via facebook.com - Aug 14, 2021
Traveling in from Roanoke, we met a Williamsburg friend to have dinner---what a treat! The ambiance was lovely and inviting, our waiter was charming and efficient, the food (as we anticipated from previous visits) was delicious! Quiet enough to have a real conversation, it was enjoyable from start to finish. We will continue to p ... read more
Patricia Eby via google.com - Aug 12, 2021
Grand experience. Delicious food and gracious staff!
Grand experience. Delicious food and gracious staff!
Alan B Colvin Sr via facebook.com - Aug 11, 2021
Classic fancy restaurant. Food, atmosphere and service were excellent but the portions were too small for the prices charged and the selection was too limited. We went for our anniversary and it was great for a once every other year kind of place. If you're in town on vacation and have the money, check it out.
Joe Hause via google.com - Aug 11, 2021
We dined here for our birthday this year, myself, my mother and my aunt. The service was wonderful
We dined here for our birthday this year, myself, my mother and my aunt. The service was wonderful and the food was beyond amazing! Our entire dining experience from start to finish was wonderful! I couldn’t have been more pleased with everything. We will definitely return again!! Thank you for making our birthday a great one! ♥️ ... read more
Dante Gaskins via facebook.com - Aug 8, 2021
We enjoyed an excellent meal at The Seafare this evening. We were immediately greeted upon opening the door. Customer service here is top notch. It was nice to see white cloth tablecloths and cloth napkins. The antique brass nautical equipment and sea themed paintings helped to elevate the decor. Our server did an excellent job, ... read more
Andrew Payne via google.com - Aug 7, 2021
Delicious food and over the top service. Would highly recommend for an excellent seafood meal and dining experience.
Bert Hudson via google.com - Aug 5, 2021
Excellent food and attentive service.
Excellent food and attentive service.
KelleyL via opentable.com - Aug 2, 2021
Service was good. A little slow at times but they were busy and they may have been light on staff co
Service was good. A little slow at times but they were busy and they may have been light on staff considering the current employment climate. We enjoyed our meal.
KevinQ via opentable.com - Jul 30, 2021
This is my absolute favorite restaurant in the entire US. We went last night for our anniversary and
This is my absolute favorite restaurant in the entire US. We went last night for our anniversary and I wish I remembered our waitress's name but she was absolutely amazing and so was the food. If the owners see this it was to the left of the entrance at the first table on the right at about 5:30 pm. I would love if you would praise h ... read more
Alicia R. via yelp.com - Jul 25, 2021
The inside of the restaurant was absolutely beautiful. was like exquisite dining on a luxury cruise
The inside of the restaurant was absolutely beautiful. was like exquisite dining on a luxury cruise line. Food was delicious. Staff was very friendly and professional. Would rate this a "9"! Always room for improvement. But I don't know what they could do.
Carolann Adams via facebook.com - Jul 22, 2021
Omg this was like the best of everything the greatest meal ever and you can't beat the price ... read more
Paula Wauhop via google.com - Jul 10, 2021
Very good food ... read more
Clifton Brown via google.com - Jul 7, 2021
Awesome dinner. Awesome service. Highly recommend.
greg smith via google.com - Jul 7, 2021
Great service . Great food ... read more
Jay Lycan via google.com - Jun 30, 2021
We’ve visited a few times and are always impressed with the service and food. It’s a must try— you w
We’ve visited a few times and are always impressed with the service and food. It’s a must try— you will want to return, I promise!
kellymB2293CQ via tripadvisor.com - Jun 30, 2021
Some food was good, esp fried oysters, scallops. Others were under seasoned. The mango sorbet pallet
Some food was good, esp fried oysters, scallops. Others were under seasoned. The mango sorbet pallet reset was very good. We didn’t mind the darkness, and the server was very nice and not overbearing. Service was a little slow despite not having too many present. Overall, we’d come back.
OpenTable Diner via opentable.com - Jun 28, 2021
Everything was Awesome. Couldn't have been better. 4 of us and everyone's food was delicious. Very a
Everything was Awesome. Couldn't have been better. 4 of us and everyone's food was delicious. Very attentive ... read more
896christianner via tripadvisor.com - Jun 28, 2021
Great family restaurant ... read more
Kevin Horn via google.com - Jun 27, 2021
Nice. Superb food and service
Nice. Superb food and service ... read more
Melinda Blue via facebook.com - Jun 25, 2021
This week we had two wonderful dinners at Seafare of Williamsburg on different nights. The food was
This week we had two wonderful dinners at Seafare of Williamsburg on different nights. The food was so good on our first visit that we had to return. The food was superb and the service was exceptional.
Farid J Sabongi via facebook.com - Jun 25, 2021
Excellent food and service
Excellent food and service ... read more
Hgrabkow via opentable.com - Jun 24, 2021
A little dark inside, making reading the menu difficult. Said from that, we had a wonderful meal and
A little dark inside, making reading the menu difficult. Said from that, we had a wonderful meal and experience.
OpenTable Diner via opentable.com - Jun 20, 2021
Fabulous food, good prices, service is great! I have dined here for decades, and the experience has
Fabulous food, good prices, service is great! I have dined here for decades, and the experience has always been exemplary. One of my favorites here in Williamsburg !
rjcfabs via tripadvisor.com - Jun 19, 2021
Great food and service. Very fresh seafood.
Great food and service. Very fresh seafood.
Porkstuff via opentable.com - Jun 15, 2021
Delicious food, exceptional service, amazing experience, beautiful atmosphere, would love to visit again!
SaranghaeBTSDaily via google.com - Jun 11, 2021
The atmosphere was very cozy. The staff was attentive to us. Plus everyone very friendly & polite. The food was delicious. We will definitely return ... read more
Towana Harris-Lawson via google.com - Jun 7, 2021
This place has a great atmosphere. We love the decor and lighted pictures on the walls. Gives a rom
This place has a great atmosphere. We love the decor and lighted pictures on the walls. Gives a romantic feel. The bathroom needs to be updated to reflect the same atmosphere as the restaurant but overall, it’s a really nice and elegant setting. Food is really delicious! Their seafood is top of the line and their 12 oz steak was so t ... read more
Aleshia Condia Long via facebook.com - Jun 6, 2021
We had an enjoyable dinner - but they are not offering the fixed price multi-course dinners. We were
We had an enjoyable dinner - but they are not offering the fixed price multi-course dinners. We were served 3 kinds of bread, which were all excellent.
Irene L via tripadvisor.com - Jun 1, 2021
We had a wonderful time. Our waitress was amazing and the food was GREAT! We loved the atmosphere and highly recommend Seafare if you are looking for a romantic dinner and great seafood!
Katie Reid via google.com - May 31, 2021
Great Food. Slow Service.
Clark Hemingway via google.com - May 30, 2021
We have always enjoyed this restaurant! It’s a step back in time both in style of service, decor and
We have always enjoyed this restaurant! It’s a step back in time both in style of service, decor and menu. Service is gracious and timely. The food is tasty and well portioned with no surprises or missing elements. We will return!
ALT1 via opentable.com - May 25, 2021
love the food and the staff was amazing
love the food and the staff was amazing ... read more
Priscilla Phillips via facebook.com - May 16, 2021
Excellent experience for fine dining. Very romantic anytime we visit Williamsburg we have decided to make this our special place ... read more
Pashun 4 Life via google.com - May 15, 2021
The food was great.
Scott Rauenzahn via google.com - May 14, 2021
We had reservations and were seated quickly. Server was very attentive. We had grilled oysters, crab
We had reservations and were seated quickly. Server was very attentive. We had grilled oysters, crab bisque. Followed that with serf and turf. Grilled Lobster was best I have had anywhere. Everything was excellent. Wish I lived here because we would eat here often.
scott via opentable.com - May 11, 2021
Want To Tell Us About Your Experience?
GoogleMyBusinessFoursquareFacebookYelpZomatoTwitterTrip AdvisorYouTubeGrouponInstagramOpen TablePinterestZagatFlickrLinkedInTumblrTheKnotWeddingWire